LAURA BÉCQUER PASEIRO
BRAZIL is constantly gaining more
recognition as a world economic power. However, like
the majority of so-called Third World nations, there
remains much to be done to overcome the effects of
underdevelopment, forged by slave-holding
colonialism and subsequent neoliberalism. Health is
one of the sectors for which there have been strong
aspirations since the coming to power of the Workers’
Party (PT), first with President Luiz Inácio Lula da
Silva and then with the current leader, Dilma
Rousseff.
Popular protests which took place in
June of this year accelerated the approval of
various measures under discussion in Congress, which
were being met with a certain resistance. Among them,
that of directing 75% of oil income to education,
and 25% to health, in response to citizens’ demands
for better health care.
The following month, a proposal was
approved for the health program Mais Médicos, with a
view to meeting the shortage of professionals in the
sector, a systemic problem which is not exclusive to
medicine and was aggravated by former neoliberal
governments more concerned by IMF prescriptions than
the population’s quality of life.
However, in the Brazilian case, the
problem is not only the lack of qualified personnel,
but their territorial distribution. A large portion
of professionals in the country won’t work in
remote, poor areas of the interior, in their
majority in the north and northeast, usually citing
the lack of infrastructure.
Brazil is among countries with the
lowest rate of medical density per inhabitant, with
just 1.8 doctors for every 1,000 persons. The most
affected regions are in the north and northeast,
historically backward in relation to the south.
There, the states with the lowest density are
Maranhão (0.58), Amapá (0.76), Pará (0.77) and Piauí
(0.92). The states with the highest density are: the
Federal District (3.46), Río de Janeiro (3.44), Sao
Paulo (2.49) and Rio Grande do Sul (2.23).
The concentration of doctors in the
richest areas of the south is compounded by the fact
that the generation of open positions there is
higher than the number of professionals in training.
In 2011 alone, close to 19,000 jobs were created,
but only 13,000 students of Medicine graduated,
according to official figures.
Data from the Brazilian Ministry of
Health indicate that in terms of primary health
care, more than 1,900 municipalities have less than
one doctor per 3,000 inhabitants. A Ministry
investigation showed that in rural and suburban
areas, where violence rules, the work of doctors is
made much more difficult, and to remain working in
these places is a tremendous challenge.
The government goal is to reach 2.7
doctors per 1,000 inhabitants, but that requires
168,424 health professionals.
This is where the role of Mais
Médicos comes into play. Among other measures, the
plan proposes the contracting of foreign specialists
to serve citizens in rural and isolated areas, not
currently reached by Brazilian specialists.
Doctors contracted from countries
such as Cuba, Spain, Portugal, Argentina and Uruguay
receive a four-week training course prior to
beginning work. These doctors can only work for the
Sistema Único de Saúde (Single Health System), which
receives a federal budget but is administered by
mayoralties.
After signing the law which
constituted Mais Médicos, Rousseff emphasized that
three months into the initiative, 4.2 million
citizens had received medical treatment.
‘Mais Médicos is beginning to change
the nation’s health system and its implementation
signifies fewer patients in the large hospitals,
fewer lines, better attention and less overloaded
professionals," she noted.
She also emphasized that by the end
of 2013, more than 3,500 doctors will be
incorporated into the program.
However, the government is aware
that this initiative will not solve the problem. In
this context, Brazilian Health Minister Alexandre
Padilha, commented, "We know that we are not going
to immediately solve the country’s health problems,
but this is an important step, which is supported by
the people."
That is why government measures
include training for a further 2,415 doctors in
2014, and new openings in the states that most need
them.
Despite its noble intentions, Mais
Médicos met with resistance from some sectors of the
Brazilian health unions. This has been overcome with
the strong support of the population most in need,
the focus of the project, who have defended their
right to decent primary health care.