Water in Santiago
de Cuba:
an urgent challenge
José Antonio Torres
TRANSFORMING Santiago de Cuba into the first city
in the country to solve the problem of supplying
water to its entire population is the impetus behind
the actions and endeavors of the 2,000-plus workers
from 11 provinces who are working on this project.
The comprehensive rehabilitation of Santiago’s
water system is a colossal task, which will have a
tremendous impact and be of popular benefit, and it
is putting to the test the level of organization and
response capacity of planners and engineers from
several different ministries.
Gradually, a transformative change is beginning
to be perceived. While during other stages, there
was a lack of rigor and demand on the part of the
local authorities, the Ministry of Construction (MICONS)
and the National Institute of Hydraulic Resources (INRH),
these deficiencies are currently being overcome with
greater control and supervision over the quality of
the work being undertaken.
Assessing the project, Commander of the
Revolution Ramiro Valdés Menéndez, vice president of
the Councils of State and Ministers, stated that the
work underway is far removed from the improvisation
and lack of foresight that characterized the
beginning of the project.
Making a more precise analysis, he emphasized
that never before has Cuba embarked on a project of
such magnitude, making it imperative that we
confront obstacles that arise from the project,
thinking in terms of savings and utility.
In his opinion, providing Santiago de Cuba with a
modern, safe and stable hydraulic system requires a
financial investment of close to 150 million pesos,
as well as the mobilization of specialized teams and
forces from all over the country.
One constant appeal in his conversations with
construction workers and leaders is the need to
assume a more active role in controlling resources,
as a premise for exploiting efficiency reserves and
dealing with delays in the timeframe of the project.
Valdés Menéndez, also a member of the Political
Bureau of the Communist Party, stressed that
systematic checks, together with a self-critical
analysis of errors, would allow workers to correctly
approach the project, which is not only INRH’s
principal investment, but also the most important
project undertaken in this territory.
He remarked that although the progress made is
unquestionable and the level of satisfaction is
growing, deficiencies still persist that are
impairing state efforts, provoking additional
spending and aggravating the public.
He reserved particular criticism for what
happened at the Quintero 1 waterworks where the
filtration station is being reconstructed due to
serious damage and other problems detected during
the operational stage.
THE EFFECTS OF RECKLESSNESS
In that context, an official from the Ministry of
Construction announced that ineptitude and shoddy
work meant that the wall veneers collapsed and the
filter plant tiles failed during the backwash test.
The reports by two expert commissions – created
by MININT and MICONS – concluded that ECOI 11, Villa
Clara’s Planning Company and the INRH delegation
responsible for the task up until the beginning of
this year were responsible for the negligence and
the resulting delays.
For his part, an official from the National
Institute of Hydraulic Resources commented that the
tests were carried out in violation of technical
regulations. It is incongruous to make an
announcement that works are completed if that is not
the case or for handover documents to be issued,
signed by individuals lacking the authority to
validate the Institute’s works.
The situation created is a direct consequence of
recklessness during earlier stages which generated
severe criticisms at the beginning of the year from
President Raúl Castro of high-ranking officials at
the Ministry of Construction and the National
Institute of Hydraulic Resources, provincial cadres
from those organizations and the Administrative
Council in Santiago de Cuba province responsible for
the work, during a joint meeting of the Committee of
the Political Bureau of the Party and the Executive
Committee of the Council of Ministers.
During that meeting, attended by those
responsible for the deficiencies in the execution of
the water system, Raúl strongly criticized the lack
of organization, the tolerant attitude of the
management cadres at various levels and the
tawdriness in comprehending the priority required –
and needed – to solve one of the most urgent
problems facing the population of Santiago.
He also instructed Commander of the Revolution
Ramiro Valdés Menéndez, as vice president of the
Council of Ministers attending to the sector, and "who
has been rigorously fulfilling that task since then,"
to adopt all the appropriate measures in order to
rectify the execution of the project, in accordance
with Compañero Raúl’s most recent evaluations.
On that occasion, he also proposed the
appointment of compañera Inés Chapman, member
of the Council of State and at that time the INRH
delegate in Holguín province, as program coordinator
for the implementation of the Santiago de Cuba
aqueduct to which, in her modest way, she has
devoted herself in order to fulfill this mission.
Inés studied at CUJAE University where she
graduated as a hydraulic engineer in July 1988. In
September of that year, she went on to study for a
Masters degree in hydraulic engineering at Delft
University in Holland. She has a postgraduate degree
from the University of Holguín and is a full cadre
of the Communist Party, which she joined at 27 years
of age. She was also secretary of the Base Committee
at the university where she studied.
The analysis undertaken at that meeting sought to
ensure that the colossal effort being undertaken by
the state should not be tarnished by negligent or
irresponsible attitudes.
ERRADICATING DEFICIENCIES
An official from the Provincial Administration
Council stated that those deficiencies were the most
controversial issue and the most-hotly debated topic
that arose during the most recent People’s Power
accountability meeting.
"From that moment," the official acknowledged, "a
transformative change occurred. We analyzed the
problems. The delegates visited the project site, we
drew from our experiences, we assumed the
responsibility that corresponded to us from the
beginning, which we had not done at the time.
"Faced with a large number of complaints, we
created working groups within the People’s Councils
so that the population could express their opinions
on the renovation works.
"Letting the population participate in the
efforts of the hydrometric sector was a satisfactory
initiative because it increased the flow of
information on the quality and efficiency of the
project.
"These action groups are an irreplaceable
arrangement. In them, delegates and voters give
their opinions, gain awareness of the complexity of
the work being undertaken in a city with half a
million inhabitants and which needs to be undertaken
without paralyzing their basic services, such as
water and transportation.
"The population is cooperating and supporting the
project on a mass scale. You cannot confront a
project of such collective benefit in any other way.
In all the People’s Councils, residents are working
shoulder to shoulder with the construction workers.
"It is comforting to know that there is
collective recognition for the work of the thousands
of people who are not even thinking about rest or
vacations because of their commitment to the project.
"Although there is still a great deal to do, the
implementation of double shifts, the conclusion of
30 unfinished projects, establishing a definitive
timetable for all the working groups and providing
the government with a outline that will allow it
fully assume its role as investor are just some of
the measures that will permit us to approach the
implementation of the project with greater
objectivity.
"This occurred after the criticisms leveled and
that is how the Integrated Management of the project
and the Administrative Council – via its Engineering
Services Company – have been demanding since then
the descriptive memory of the system, whether they
accept or not the final quality of the works and
that it is their responsibility to demand solutions
from MICONS and the INRH in the case of possible
faults.
"We have the necessary resources and manpower to
finish the Santiago de Cuba aqueduct and the El
Caney and Boniato connection by November 2010; while
in 2011 we will adjust the system in order to
measure and regulate water pressure in such a way
that we will be able to guarantee equal and
simultaneous distribution to every home. We are
going to automate the service, build the
infrastructure and set up networks for the villages
of El Cobre, Siboney, Mar Verde and El Cristo."
These adjustments are important. Because of its
mountainous topography, there are different water
pressures in Santiago, and stability in 24-hour
distribution will not depend on the pumping station
or the operation of the waterworks but on the
equilibrium of pressure at the highest and lowest
points. Once this major project to guarantee water
supply to the city is concluded, adjustments will
have to be made to the entire network, otherwise
certain areas will receive more water than others.
THE RENOVATION
Various aqueducts in Santiago de Cuba date back
to the 1920s and approximately 500 of the 900-plus
kilometers of hydraulic networks have been
functioning for 80 to 100 years.
A population increase, over-exploitation of the
system and lack of maintenance aggravated the
situation to the extent that more than 61% of
potable water pumped did not reach its destination.
Assessing the progress of the program, a regional
INRH official explained that the principal delays
are located in the main distribution pipes, repairs
to the San Juan tanks and the waterworks.
"The arguments may be diverse but it is a fact
that we lacked energy and exigency in terms of
avoiding a readjustment of the timeframe and
reconsidering the investment program. Something
similar happened with the internal networks, where
pipe connections were prioritized without first
testing to see whether water was reaching people’s
homes."
He was emphatic when it came to stating that on
many occasions, and in the very same hydrometric
sector, specialists have had to confront and solve
the pressure differences created by disparities in
the terrain; in order to avoid major difficulties, a
parallel system to the existing one is being set up,
which will not be disconnected until the new
connection has been certified.
The official explained that around 110 million
pesos has been invested in the project, thus
demanding maximum efficiency. He said that the
restitution of the networks, the links between
faucets inside homes and pipes are presenting
deficiencies, on many occasions long after the test
phase and operation is underway.
In reality, one of the problems that has to be
solved with the population is the solution for the
entry of water into their homes. It will be very
difficult to maintain a stable around-the-clock
supply while adjustments to the pressure of the
supply system throughout the city are not concluded
and direct connections to homes are being repaired.
In the same way, it is essential to modify water
rates, given that the current price is symbolic and
does not encourage rationality in the use of this
precious resource.
He confirmed that exigency is increasing among
all the collectives and there are daily assessments
on the progress of the project, the errors committed
and their consequences.
One head of a brigade and a quality control
supervisor agreed that the measures adopted are to
be directed at eliminating all the obstacles that
are hindering the normal development of the repair
works.
The new aqueduct will guarantee water supplies to
every home in Santiago de Cuba. The experiences
derived from the project will subsequently be
extended to other cities in the future.
A national MICONS official confirmed that the
production and handover of piping, accessories and
other resources necessary for a project of this
scale have all been guaranteed.
"Street resurfacing, the fixing of exterior combs
on multi-family buildings – of which more than 1,000
have been placed – and assembling valves to improve
water pressure are separate programs to that of
renewing the aqueduct; its completion corresponds to
a project to be carried out at a later date by the
Housing Office.
Another national leader, in this case from the
Hydraulic Resources Institute, confirmed that
Santiago de Cuba boasts the most qualified personnel
in the country working in the field of renovation.
All the construction enterprises, one specialist
team and four project centers are working full-time
in the region. Twelve network brigades, four pipe
distribution brigades, and three MICONS crews are
completing the effort.
The directors of national companies and those
from other provinces undertook an evaluation of all
areas of the job underway. Mechanization specialists
are maintaining the exploitation rate of the teams
at above 80% of their productive capacity.
Water, he added, is a very expensive product that
is subsidized by the state. The INRH is the third
highest consumer of energy at national level. In
Santiago de Cuba alone, some 20,000 CUC is invested
every month in order to purchase the chlorine,
sulfate and hypochlorite required by the waterworks.
"The renovations will reorder the service and
eliminate illegalities. Damage to the conduits -
where there are pipes of up to 90 millimeters in
diameter that have a fragile connection – is still
being reported. In the stretch between El Cobre,
Melgarejo and La Caoba, 380 liters of water per
second is lost or does not reach its destination.
"The completion of the conduit that links the
Charco Mono reservoir with the Sierra Maestra tunnel,
constructed by the FAR from 1993 to 1994 working
almost 24 hours a day, facilitates the arrival of
water by gravity and eliminates the six tons of fuel
consumed per day by the generators for transferring
water from the Gota Blanca pumping station to
Santiago de Cuba, which will increase the entry of
the precious liquid to the city."
QUALITY SUPERVISION
The renovation has passed through various stages
and had different focuses, but everything has been
conceived to construct an efficient, lasting and
reliable system.
An official from the People’s Power Engineering
Services Enterprise confirmed that specialists have
noted the restitution of faulty sections and solders.
He mentioned cases of operatives who have damaged
underground elements by ignoring the technical
indications. Other situations have arisen due to the
fact that representatives from the institutions have
not been on site.
The deficiencies coincide – he added – with
complaints from the population and are concentrated
on the failings of renovated sectors, leaks, a lack
of synchronization between digging and repaving the
streets, problems with the construction sequence and
negligent attitudes, such as the theft of resources
on site.
One recurring problem – and which influenced the
arrears – was that the work was checked at the
beginning but without taking into account the issue
of its completion date, the impact it would have and
its handover.
To date, 11 main distribution pipes have been
finished and they are working on the remaining ones.
It is unavoidable that work on certain conduits,
where services have been available for months, has
not been completed because one or two registrations
are still unresolved.
The networks have a 12-month guarantee to assess
their operation, adjust the system and comply with
the protocol establishing the technological package.
The comprehensive supervision team is made up of 22
highly-experienced technicians.
A construction specialist acknowledged the
progress made with respect to quality; nevertheless,
he warned about deficiencies in the conduit between
the Quintero Pumping Station and Micro 9 in the José
Martí District. He was unequivocal that this work
did not respect the profiles and had violated other
instructions.
For his part, an exterior pipes supervisor
referred to changes made in this section, which was
the issue that triggered criticism in the earlier
analysis at the beginning of the year and which
today, is one of the areas of work that is
functioning better and displaying savings in the
investment.
"We have stepped up security measures and
supervision of the work where more explosives had
been used than planned. In the same way, we
controlled the connections and compacting of the
pipes crossing a significant section of the mountain
range surrounding the city, which have to withstand
tremendous pressure in order to guarantee water
supplies to the population there.
"During the process, we instructed the repetition
of certain solders and five 1,000 millimeter pipes
that were not of the same quality and were
improperly used.
"As a consequence, today work is ahead of
schedule and there have been savings to the budget
as a result of the reorientation of the plan without
damaging the aim of the project, which is that the
water enters by gravity.
"The substitution of blocks and cement for waste
pipes has had an influence on financial savings.
Normally, they are worth more than 3,000 pesos and,
using this construction, now the price does not
exceed 250 pesos."
WITHIN SANTIAGO
In a tour of the city, Granma was able to
verify improvements to the coastal region, the José
Martí District, the Abel Santamaría District,
Agüero, Nuevo Vista Alegre, Santa Elena, Sueño,
Marimón, Asunción, Pastorita and Rajayoga.
Other hydrometric sectors are partially or
completely resolved, while work is being speeded up
to establish supplies to the communities of Flores,
Mariana de la Torre, Chicharrones y Sevilla,
Altamira and Vista Hermosa.
The renovation of the historic center, where the
thickness of the paving and the high number of
underground elements is complex, has created
particular tension. In the higher areas, the system
has been replaced by one that is truly operative and
will guarantees service to some 35,000 people.
It is imperative that experts assess the
feasibility of replacing approximately 20 kilometers
of interior piping and distribution networks that
are in good condition but have been used for several
decades now. This is the moment of planning; when
the project is finished the country will not be a
position to approve additional spending.
For the time being, specialists are using modern
technology to produce a definitive report. Video
cameras, slipways, pressure tests, visual
examinations, assessments of the rate of burst pipes,
and diagnostic inspection within the network will
determine the procedure to be followed. It is a fact
that, for every kilometer of pipeline repaired by
the state, there are savings of one million pesos.
Progress is being made – although not at the
required speed – on the paving of drains on the
streets. More than 42,000 water meters have been
installed, of the 83,000 that are planned for urban
areas.
An official from Aguas Santiago corroborated the
notable improvement to the Parada and Quintero
systems, which are responsible for more than 90% of
water distribution in this city.
A different panorama can be witnessed at the San
Juan reservoirs, where tanks and extraction
batteries are being repaired, given that their
deterioration has resulted in a water loss off 70
liters per second, due to lack of attention to the
supply sources in order to guarantee the volume of
flow demanded by the system, plus a growth in the
population in that area.
Soon the new pipe loading bay will be operational.
It is conceived for an eventual or exceptional
situation, which will impact on the reduction of San
Juan’s extraction levels, estimated at 70 journeys
and 400 cubic meters of water per working day.
Santiago de Cuba was reporting 2,000 to 2,100
leaks per month. Currently, within the rehabilitated
sectors still in the setting-up stage, 20-30 leaks
of this nature are being repaired.
One underlying problem is the situation of the
sewer system, which is growing worse as the aqueduct’s
efficiency improves. In the last six months, 2,700
blockages have been eliminated, but its
deterioration is still provoking dozens of
breakdowns daily.
Within the plans, it was never foreseen
undertaking the two works simultaneously. Santiago
is possibly one of the Cuban cities with the largest
sewage system, with approximately 290 kilometers of
networks covering 95% of the urban area of the city.
There are areas where the evacuation capacity is
insufficient, others in which 10,000 to 15,000
inhabitants live without access to the system and,
to a large extent, the city does not have the final
treatment for waste water and pumps it directly into
the sea. Further investments will have to be made
later on, as the networks could start to present
problems given their scant functioning over a many
years due to lack of water, compounded by the fact
that there has been zero maintenance of the sewage
system.
Now, when all the houses have running water,
virtually 80% of what is consumed will go into the
sewage system, thus making it necessary to set up a
strong maintenance team with the essential
technology for cleaning every hydrometric sector.
VISIBLE ADVANCE IN THE PROGRAM
Another investment director assured me that the
rehabilitation is at 82% of execution. More than 900
kilometers of networks have been laid, as well as 64
conduits, 1,800 connecting pipes main distribution
pipes.
"Eight of the hydrometric sectors have been
completed and work is going ahead to complete
another 12, which has benefited 400,000 inhabitants
and is reducing the handover cycles, which were
oscillating between 20-60 days on average.
Each sector has its director, a commercial office
with communications and resources to provide
maintenance, solve obstructions and preserve the
system’s operability. The complete process includes
the rehabilitation of 118, 870 homes. The
calibration and adjustment of the distribution
circuits will be delayed for about 12 months.
Another 60,000 people – located in 66 barrios
that have never received the service or were
affected by a non-operational aqueduct – are now
being benefited, particularly those communities that
have lacked a stable water supply for 25 to 30 years.
The deficiencies are being left behind, the
director noted, adding: "Today the distribution
frequency is oscillating between three and eight
days, with the exception of the San Juan system,
where the storage and distribution tanks are being
repaired."
A number of networks were laid years ago, but
without guaranteeing the water flow needed by their
population nuclei. The lack of integration made the
situation worse. Although advances are underway,
some of its barrios are still being affected by
cycles in excess of 12 days, but are progressively
improving as the system’s effectiveness is being
raised.
Works being redone in the Quintero waterworks are
going well. As a preventive measure, some of the
construction solutions being executed there will be
taken into account during interventions in the other
plants. Its capital reparation is part of a program
designed to stabilize the service, renew the
disinfection process, reduce bacteriological
vulnerabilities and give the territory better
conditions to assess the physical-chemical treatment
of the water.
The challenge is a huge one. It is not enough to
know where the problems lie, but what has to be done
to solve them in order to make a reality of the
publicly given promise at the central event for the
26th of July in the polygon of the former Moncada
Garrison.